SB01 Dead to Me Read online

  A collection of photographs from the crime scene was doing the rounds along with a preliminary post-mortem report. Rachel realized the DCI had gone straight from the crime scene to the post-mortem and she had probably worked all night collating this while they had trotted off home. Now seven a.m. and her ladyship was sparky, her face a bit pale maybe but her eyes shining as she got into her stride.

  ‘Lisa Finn,’ the DCI said, ‘seventeen years old, looked-after child until this April. Lisa is known to our Community colleagues for drug abuse and shoplifting. Cautions. Boyfriend Sean rang us at five past four to report the death, found Lisa on the living-room floor at the flat. Last saw her around ten the same morning, Monday thirteenth December. Cause of death is haemorrhage due to a stab wound to the chest. Defensive mark on the left wrist. Slight abrasions at the back of the neck. Not fingerprints, according to Ranjeet, something thin. The skin wasn’t broken, so it may not have any significance.’

  ‘A necklace?’ Janet said, peering at the mark in the photographs.

  ‘Possibly. Though it might simply be localized irritation – she was wearing something that rubbed at her neck, or she was slightly allergic.’ Gill now looked to Lee. ‘Was there a necklace at the scene?’ Lee would be the exhibits officer, responsible for ensuring the chain of custody for the whole case.

  ‘Some jewellery in the bedroom drawer, nothing in the living room,’ he said.

  ‘We also have a drop of blood here’ – she indicated the ground plan of the flat – ‘halfway to the kitchen, and another just inside the kitchen door.’

  ‘The killer moved into the kitchen holding the knife – and what, washed it?’ said Janet.

  ‘No traces in the sink,’ Gill replied. ‘Post-mortem shows signs of recent sexual activity, a forensic test found traces of lubricant from a condom.’

  ‘Rape?’ asked Janet.

  ‘We don’t know. Some bruising, could just be rough sex. No condom at the scene.’

  So he flushed it or took it. Either way, it made things harder. Rachel knew that from Sex Crimes.

  ‘DNA swabs from the body are with the lab.’

  ‘In that case we can all go home till Christmas,’ Pete said, and everyone laughed. The lab took a while to process stuff. Fingerprints could be done with fingerprint-recognition software by the officers themselves. And blood groups were pretty quick to get a label on, but all the other biological gubbins took a day or two at best.

  ‘I know.’ Gill pointed at Pete. ‘Pain in the arse.’

  Rachel watched as Kevin drew eyes, a little Hitler moustache, and breasts on his paper cup with a board marker. What a twat. Perhaps he had some relative in high command and Her Maj owed them a favour.

  ‘Kevin – with Andy on house-to-house. Mitch – friends and acquaintances. See what her fellow druggies can tell us.’

  ‘Was she on the game?’ Rachel asked. It went with the territory, one of the few ways to get money to buy the drugs.

  ‘Not to our knowledge. Janet and Rachel, get a full witness statement from Sean Broughton. Janet in the chair, Rachel – look and learn. He made an initial statement last night but we need to flesh it out.’

  ‘Here or at his?’ Rachel asked.

  ‘Do it here, make him comfy.’

  ‘I’ll talk, you write,’ Janet said to Rachel.

  ‘I’ve got tier two,’ Rachel said. Trained to know the definition of the offence and to prove each point in interviewing suspects.

  Janet looked at her. ‘You heard Gill.’ The DCI had specifically asked Janet to run the witness statement from Sean Broughton. Did she really think Janet would just roll over and give her the task because she’d asked for it?

  Rachel shrugged. ‘Fine,’ she said ungraciously.

  The boy’s eyes were dark brown, the whites bloodshot, and he had a slack look to him that made Janet suspect he was high, weed maybe, not twitchy enough for coke or crack. He wore an old Adidas trackie top and a Man City T-shirt that had seen better days, jeans, trainers, hi-tops. He had not shaved and there was a dusting of dark brown hair around his chin and upper lip. His hair was shortish and dyed the colour of hay, black roots showing. Perhaps he and Lisa had bleached their hair together? He had the coffee-coloured skin of a mixed race kid but Janet couldn’t tell what the mix was. Could have been part Indian, or African-Caribbean or something else. No clue in his name either.

  ‘Thank you for coming in, Sean. What we’re going to do,’ Janet explained once they settled into the easy chairs in the visitors’ room slash soft interview space, ‘is get a detailed witness statement from you. Now we have this camera in the corner running – nothing for you to worry about. It can feel a bit weird at first,’ she smiled, ‘but most people soon forget it’s there. There are certain things I have to go through with you as a matter of procedure. I have to tell you that you are not,’ she stressed the word, ‘under arrest, and you are free to leave at any time. I must also tell you that you don’t have to answer anything that you don’t want to answer but if we go to court, anything you say here can be used. And you can ask to speak to a solicitor or to have a solicitor present. Do you understand?’

  ‘Yes.’

  They were sitting in easy chairs, a few feet apart, nothing between them, no desk, no barriers. ‘If you need a break at any time, that’s fine, we can stop. We might be here for quite a while – we don’t want to rush things and it’s important we take the time to get everything down as you remember. Is there anything you want to ask me before we start?’

  ‘No,’ Sean said.

  ‘OK. I need you to confirm the details you gave yesterday.’ Janet went through his name, DOB and address. No surprises. ‘Thank you. Now, can you tell me how you know Lisa Finn?’

  ‘She’s my girlfriend.’ He rubbed his palms on his jeans.

  ‘And how long have you been together?’

  ‘Couple of years.’

  ‘Thank you. Now tell me in your own words what you remember from yesterday afternoon.’ Janet sat back in her seat, giving him the floor, giving him space.

  ‘I went round there about half three,’ he said, ‘went in and she were in the living room and she’s on the floor, like …’

  Janet nodded slowly. ‘Yes, keep going.’ She was barely aware of Rachel behind her making notes.

  ‘She was …’ Sean rocked forward in his chair and back again, shoved his hands between his knees, a comfort pose, a response to the distress, ‘… she was dead, like,’ he said, his nose reddening. ‘I could just tell. And I rang you.’ He choked off the end of the sentence.

  ‘Thank you,’ Janet said. The atmosphere in the room had changed. Sean’s grief thick in the air. She waited a moment, giving him time to regain his equilibrium. Janet remained composed, neutral, empathetic and professional. This is what all the weeks of interview training had taught her. ‘Now I’m going to go through your statement and ask a little more about it. So we can get a complete picture from you. Is that OK?’

  ‘Yes.’ He cleared his throat. She saw his shoulders had relaxed slightly, a sign that he was feeling less threatened. Though she knew the process was fluid, his anxiety would advance and retreat as they went back and forth over the memories of him finding Lisa’s body.

  ‘How did you get to Lisa’s?’

  ‘Walked,’ he said.

  ‘Where had you been before that?’

  ‘At my place, with my cousin Benny – he lives there too. I had to sign on in the morning and then I was at home.’ He bit at his thumbnail.

  ‘You told me you got to Lisa’s at about half past three. Did you notice the time particularly, Sean?’

  ‘That’s when I said I’d be there.’

  ‘Which way do you walk?’

  ‘Down Garrigan Street,’ he said.

  ‘Do you remember seeing anyone on the way?’

  ‘No, just … the school was coming out, on the brow, they finish at quarter past.’

  Janet gave a nod. It was good to get some supporting information on th
e basic facts, something to corroborate what a witness said. So if they got to trial there would be no chance for the defence to play silly buggers, casting doubt on the timeline and jeopardizing a conviction.

  Janet made eye contact. ‘I’d like you to think about turning into the avenue: can you remember seeing anyone there?’

  ‘I don’t know,’ he said.

  ‘Any cars moving, anyone fetching kids from school?’

  Sean licked his lips, shook his head. ‘Don’t remember.’

  ‘You get to the front door, what then?’

  ‘I went in.’

  ‘You have a key?’

  ‘Yeah, but – well, the latch is broken, so you can just push the door, if you know.’

  Janet leaned forward. ‘Lisa didn’t get it fixed?’

  ‘She was going to tell the landlord. Don’t know if she did. Take them years to sort it anyway.’

  ‘How long has it been broken?’ Janet said.

  ‘Few months.’

  Good God.

  ‘You couldn’t tell, like,’ he went on, ‘’cos the door sticks so it looks shut.’

  Janet felt a bit sick. Did this mean that Lisa could have been attacked by an intruder? Who what …? Persuaded her to undress, then got her to put a kimono on before raping and stabbing her? Or had an intruder found her half-undressed and attacked her? The broken latch only seemed to muddy the waters. What it did mean was that Lisa hadn’t necessarily invited her killer in, which is what they’d assumed until now.

  He bent forward in his chair, hands on his knees, preparing for what was coming. Janet didn’t want him to get too wound-up. Before walking him through the discovery again, the most traumatic part of his evidence, she reeled back a few hours. ‘Had you and Lisa been in contact during the day?’

  ‘I rang her just after one. She said she’d be back about half three. That’s how I knew to go round, like.’

  Janet gave a nod, reinforcing that what he was telling them was helpful, that he was doing well. ‘Sean, do you still have that call on your phone?’ she asked him.

  ‘Yeah.’

  ‘Good,’ Janet said. Physical evidence, even though it wouldn’t necessarily prove Lisa was alive at one o’clock, only that someone had used her phone then. The brighter sparks were catching on to how police used mobile phone data in investigations, and tried sending messages after the victim was dead to mislead the police. ‘We might need to keep that for our records.’

  ‘My phone?’ he said, a little worried.

  ‘Perhaps, I’ll check with our telecoms people. Sometimes they can copy the information. In case it’s needed in court.’

  He signalled his agreement.

  ‘When did you last see Lisa, before half past three?’ Janet said.

  ‘In the morning, before I went to sign on.’

  ‘You had stayed at the flat together?’

  He nodded, miserable. His eyes moist.

  Janet kept going. ‘Do you know what Lisa was planning to do?’

  ‘She was heading into town.’

  ‘For anything particular?’

  ‘Just shopping,’ he said. His voice rose on the last syllable and Janet wondered if that was to do with his sorrow or if the question itself unnerved him in some way.

  ‘Does she go shopping a lot?’ Janet asked.

  ‘Not really.’

  ‘What was she going to buy?’

  ‘Dunno.’ He was avoiding eye contact and Janet sensed that there was something about the shopping that Sean didn’t want to discuss. Had they rowed about her going? Had she wanted him to go with her?

  ‘Was she going on her own?’ Janet said.

  ‘Yeah.’ He still wouldn’t look at her. Janet didn’t want to lose him now, digging down a diversion about the shopping, so judged it was time to return to the discovery of the body.

  ‘You said in your initial statement that you went straight into the living room and saw Lisa there.’ She softened her voice, kept it even.

  ‘That’s right.’ He bit at his thumb again.

  ‘I understand this will be hard for you, Sean, but please describe to me everything you saw.’

  He swung his head down, bowing under the weight of her request. ‘She was by the sofa,’ he said, ‘on the floor, on her back.’ He shook his head, blinking rapidly, put a hand over his eyes. See no evil.

  ‘By the sofa?’ Janet echoed; she could hear Rachel writing. ‘What else did you see?’

  ‘Blood. I thought maybe she’d been shooting up – the blood all over her,’ he added, by way of explanation. ‘There was that much blood, I thought she’d messed up.’

  ‘Where was the blood?’ Janet asked him, hiding her puzzlement. She had in her mind the crime-scene photos from the book, the lumpy duvet covering the girl, part of Lisa’s face visible at the top of it, half-covered with her hair. There was blood on the carpet, some on the duvet, but Sean had said it was all over her. How had Sean seen the blood?

  He swallowed.

  ‘Please can you tell me where you saw the blood?’ Janet said.

  ‘On her front and her dressing gown and the floor. All over.’ He shuffled in his seat, wanting to move away from the pictures in his head.

  Janet was still trying to work out how this fitted. ‘Please can you describe the dressing gown?’

  ‘A Chinese thing.’

  ‘Was she wearing anything else?’

  ‘No,’ Sean said. He frowned hard, bit at his lip. ‘That’s why I covered her up. Made her decent.’

  Oh, you dickhead, Janet’s first thought. Sean had completely compromised their crime scene. Behind her she heard Rachel shift about, prayed she’d keep her lip buttoned. His misguided attempt to show Lisa some respect would make it that much harder to obtain solid forensic evidence for the case. Janet could have broken the interview there, to alert Gill to the new information, but judged it wise to keep going a few more minutes.

  ‘Did Lisa usually shoot up?’ Janet asked.

  ‘No, she smoked. She didn’t like needles.’

  ‘OK. Where did you get the duvet from, Sean?’

  ‘The bedroom.’

  ‘When you covered Lisa up, did you touch her?’

  ‘No,’ he said, quickly, his face drawn, eyes troubled, frightened by the thought.

  ‘Did you notice anything out of place?’

  ‘The table was broke,’ he said.

  ‘Which table?’

  ‘Coffee table,’ he said.

  ‘Where was the coffee table?’

  ‘Next to Lisa.’

  ‘Lisa was between the table and the sofa?’

  ‘Yes,’ he said.

  ‘Did you touch anything else in the room?’

  ‘No.’ He looked away, staring at his hands.

  Janet paused a moment to see if he’d renew eye contact, but he didn’t. ‘Did you take anything from the flat?’

  ‘No,’ he answered, almost before she’d finished asking the question. Defensive. Something that made him uneasy.

  ‘I’m going to have to ask you some very personal questions, Sean. I’m only asking them because they are crucial for our investigation, you understand?’

  He dipped his head once.

  ‘When did you and Lisa last have sex?’

  ‘Last night,’ he said. ‘I mean, the night before,’ correcting himself.

  ‘Sunday night,’ Janet clarified.

  ‘Yeah.’

  ‘OK, and did you use a condom on that occasion?’

  He shook his head. ‘She’s got an implant.’

  Janet smiled. Safe-sex messages had obviously gone right over this lad’s head. ‘After you covered Lisa with the duvet, what did you do?’

  ‘I went outside and rang the police. I couldn’t stay in there.’ He pressed a fist to his mouth, scowling, eyes downcast.

  ‘Sean, do you know how long you spent in the flat before you called the police?’ He’d got there at half three, the call for help was five past four. What was he doing in that time? />
  ‘No.’ Suddenly he was swiping his fingers at his eyes, no longer able to keep from weeping.

  Janet waited a moment, then spoke: ‘Sean, we’ll have a break now,’ she said. ‘I’m sorry this is so distressing for you, but it helps us to do our job, it helps us find out who did this to Lisa. Is there anything else you want to tell me before we break?’

  He shook his head.

  ‘Would you like anything to eat or drink, or a cigarette break?’

  ‘Yeah, a Coke,’ he said, ‘and a smoke.’ He sniffed loudly and clenched his mouth tight. Janet pulled a face in sympathy. Poor bastard.

  7

  GILL WAS RILED, summing up for the team: ‘So, we’ve Mr Shit-for-brains to thank for coming over all prudish and ruining our crime scene.’ She turned to Janet, ‘Did he touch anything else?’

  ‘Says not.’

  ‘You believe him?’

  ‘No,’ Janet said.

  ‘Mitch?’ Gill invited him to chip in. The big lad was ex-army, a gentle giant. He was a good detective – they all were, bar Kevin, but Gill was determined to turn him round. His old boss had claimed Kevin was irredeemable, but Gill loved a challenge. Though she was beginning to wonder if Kevin was a lost cause. He didn’t seem to learn from his mistakes, just repeated them bigger and better. Self-criticism of a woodlouse.

  Mitch spoke: ‘Sean Broughton in the system, fine for possession of Class B, cannabis. Oldham magistrates, five months ago.’

  ‘Not a caution?’ Gill asked, the usual policy for that offence.

  ‘Already had two.’

  ‘Naughty step not working for him,’ Gill said. ‘There were signs of Class As at the scene.’

  ‘Paraphernalia,’ Lee said. ‘No drugs recovered, though.’